The best lighthouse is the one that fits your plan. For sweeping, rugged coastline views, Beavertail and Point Judith are hard to beat. For a dressed-up surprise, Castle Hill and Goat Island are the easier choices. And for a surprise on the water, Rose Island makes a stunning backdrop during a harbor cruise.
After photographing 334 surprise proposals, I’ve learned that the most scenic spot isn’t always the best spot for a couple, because pulling off the surprise matters more than the location. For example, it can be tricky to get your partner all dressed up and then explain why you’re going for a walk around a state park or out to the Fishermen’s Memorial overlook. At Castle Hill or Goat Island, you just tell your partner you’re going to dinner, get dressed up, and then take a stroll to the lighthouse. No questions asked.
It really does come down to the person. I recently had a client skip Goat Island, which arguably has the best lighthouse photo opportunities, because he wanted the sweeping ocean views of a wilder spot. Honestly, they’re all wonderful. My job is to help you find the lighthouse that fits your partner, your story and your plan.